Polygraphing Players Is Not Cricket

Steve Waugh
Polygraph advocate Steve Waugh

Guardian reporter David Hopps reports in a story published by the Sydney Morning Herald that former Australia cricket team captain Steve Waugh is advocating the use of lie detectors in an attempt to root out corruption in the scandal-plagued sport. Excerpt:

ANDREW Strauss and Mahendra Singh Dhoni will be encouraged to help stamp out corruption in cricket by taking lie-detector tests as the MCC uses the occasion of the 2000th Test match to step up its campaign to clean up the game.

The controversial proposal is the brainchild of former Australia captain Steve Waugh, who wants leading captains such as Strauss and Dhoni to act as ambassadors and role models by voluntarily putting their reputations on the line.

But the proposal is not supported by the Australian Cricketers’ Association, because lie-detector tests are not admissible in court.

”I applaud Steve Waugh for looking at creative and proactive ways to deal with corruption, but we wouldn’t support the use of polygraphs at this point in time,” ACA chief executive Paul Marsh said. ”Results can be affected if you’re nervous or under stress or whatever, so there may be reasons, other than not telling the truth, that you fail it and we couldn’t open players up to that.”

Waugh is at Lord’s as chairman of an MCC world cricket committee working party that was charged last year with investigating ways corruption might be eradicated. He made his chief proposal only metres away from where Strauss and Dhoni supervised practice ahead of a Test series that will decide whether England or India finish the summer as the No 1 team in the world.

The Australia Cricketers’ Association is right to reject lie detector “testing,” as it has no scientific basis. While polygraphy is inherently biased against truth-tellers, the “test” can trivially be defeated using simple countermeasures that anyone can learn and polygraph operators cannot detect.

Continue reading Polygraphing Players Is Not Cricket

“Cool Response to Lie-Tests Proposal”

The British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) reports on a proposal under consideration by the International Cricket Conference (ICC) to require Test cricketers to submit to polygraph interrogations every six months. Excerpt:

Player representatives have given a cool response to a proposal to make Test cricketers undergo lie detector tests every six months as part of the fight to stamp out match-fixing.

It is one of a range of measures being considered by the International Cricket Council in an attempt to improve the game’s image.

The introduction of lie detectors was mooted by Judge Edwin King in his report on South Afirca’s match-fixing inquiry, set up following the sacking of former captain Hansie Cronje.

The ICC will discuss the matter further at a meeting next week.

But David Graveney, joint chief executive of the Federation of International Cricketers’ Associations (FICA), told BBC Sport Online the idea “may be bordering on the unreasonable”.

He said: “Lie detection is something that legally you have to look at in order to protect the player.

“We’d support reasonable and proper measures but we are still duty bound to defend the liberty of an individual.

“As far as I can see, a lot of people have serious reservations.”

Graveney’s view echoed that of Tim May, the other joint chief of FICA and head of the Australian Cricketers Association.

“We’re keen to put in reasonable procedures to ensure we can eradicate match-fixing from the game, but there are reasonable procedures and unreasonable procedures.

“My gut feeling at this stage, without knowing the reliability of lie detectors, is this may well be on the unreasonable side,” he said.