Basing her decision in part on polygraph evidence admitted at trial against the prosecutor’s objection, Summit County Common Pleas Judge Judy Hunter on Monday, 20 August 2007 found Sahil Sharma of New York City innocent of felony sexual battery and two misdemeanor charges. While the text of Judge Hunter’s decision is not yet available, AntiPolygraph.org has obtained pre-trial polygraph testimony as well as video of a polygraph examination that was played in open court. For commentary, see Critique of Louis I. Rovner’s Polygraph Examination and Testimony in Ohio v. Sharma on the AntiPolygraph.org message board.
In Ohio, Fate of an 18-Year-Old on Trial for Murder Depends in Part on the Results of a Lie Detector Test
In Elyria, Ohio, 18-year-old Willie Evans IV is standing trial as an adult for the 2006 murder of Michael Smith. Evans, who was a minor when the crime was committed, is being tried as an adult and faces the possibility of a life sentence. Ohio is one of a number of states in which polygraph … Read more