Post reply

Welcome to AntiPolygraph.org Message Board.
Log in
Sign up

May 13, 2026, 11:16 PM

AntiPolygraph.org Message Board
► Polygraph and CVSA Forums
► Polygraph Procedure
► Post reply ( Re: Questions about polygraphs )

Post reply

The message has the following error or errors that must be corrected before continuing:: Warning: this topic has not been posted in for at least 120 days.
Unless you're sure you want to reply, please consider starting a new topic.

Name
Email
Subject
Message icon

[quote author=George W. Maschke link=msg=16876 date=1118477824]
[quote author=railroaded link=topic=0.0 date=1118425746]In a silent answer test, what is to prevent the examinee from answering a question TRUTHFULLY in his head, even if it would be incriminating if answered verbally?  For instance, if I was accused of taking $100 out of a cash register at work and was given a silent answer test, why wouldn't I just think "yes" when asked if I took the money?[/quote]

Whether or not answering the relevant questions truthfully in one's mind during a "silent answer test" would tend to increase the false negative rate is a question that has not, to my knowledge, been the subject of any competent scientific research.

[quote]Second question:  In what situations are GKT's given?  Murder, rape, arson?  Crimes where there are actual crime scenes?[/quote]

The Guilty Knowledge Test (also called a Concealed Information Test) may be used in situations where an incident is known to have occurred and investigators have information that would only be known to them and to someone who was involved with the incident. For a good explanation of this technique and how it may be employed, see "The Body on the Stairs: A Pedagogical Detective Story" (chapter 21 of the 1st edition of David T. Lykken's [i]A Tremor in the Blood: Uses and Abuses of the Lie Detector)[/i]:

http://antipolygraph.org/articles/article-037.pdf
[/quote]

Attachments: (Clear attachments)

Restrictions: 4 per post (4 remaining), maximum total size 192 KB, maximum individual size 64.00 MB

Uncheck the attachments you no longer want attached

Click or drag files here to attach them.

Insert width (px):

Insert height (px):

(Clear attachments)

Other options

Return to this topic
Don't use smileys

Verification:

Please leave this box empty:

Listen to the letters / Request another image

Type the letters shown in the picture:

Type the third word in this sentence: 'The quick brown fox jumps.' (answer in lowercase):

Shortcuts: ALT+S post or ALT+P preview

Topic summary

Posted by George W. Maschke

- Jun 11, 2005, 04:17 AM

Quote from: railroaded on Jun 10, 2005, 01:49 PMIn a silent answer test, what is to prevent the examinee from answering a question TRUTHFULLY in his head, even if it would be incriminating if answered verbally? For instance, if I was accused of taking $100 out of a cash register at work and was given a silent answer test, why wouldn't I just think "yes" when asked if I took the money?

Remember that the polygraph does not detect lies or deception. By the rationale of the "silent answer test," it doesn't matter whether or not the subject answers the question truthfully or deceptively in his head, or if he even answers at all. The assumption here is essentially the same as that behind the standard "control question test": that a guilty/deceptive person will feel more threatened by the relevant questions than by the "control" questions and will therefore show a stronger reaction to the former.

Whether or not answering the relevant questions truthfully in one's mind during a "silent answer test" would tend to increase the false negative rate is a question that has not, to my knowledge, been the subject of any competent scientific research.

QuoteSecond question: In what situations are GKT's given? Murder, rape, arson? Crimes where there are actual crime scenes?

The Guilty Knowledge Test (also called a Concealed Information Test) may be used in situations where an incident is known to have occurred and investigators have information that would only be known to them and to someone who was involved with the incident. For a good explanation of this technique and how it may be employed, see "The Body on the Stairs: A Pedagogical Detective Story" (chapter 21 of the 1st edition of David T. Lykken's A Tremor in the Blood: Uses and Abuses of the Lie Detector):

http://antipolygraph.org/articles/article-037.pdf

Posted by railroaded

- Jun 10, 2005, 01:49 PM

I have read darn near every post on this message board and have a few questions. Forgive my ignorance, but I am confused about a few things.

In a silent answer test, what is to prevent the examinee from answering a question TRUTHFULLY in his head, even if it would be incriminating if answered verbally? For instance, if I was accused of taking $100 out of a cash register at work and was given a silent answer test, why wouldn't I just think "yes" when asked if I took the money?

Second question: In what situations are GKT's given? Murder, rape, arson? Crimes where there are actual crime scenes?