AntiPolygraph.org Message Board - Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests

(Moderator: Administrator)

‹ Previous Topic | Next Topic ›

Pages: 1

Add Poll

Send Topic

Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests (Read 13169 times)

George W. Maschke Global Moderator Offline Make-believe science yields make-believe security. Posts: 6211 Joined: Sep 29^th, 2000	Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Jul 21^st, 2003 at 9:36am	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	Rowan Scarborough reports in an article in today's (21 July 2003) Washington Times titled, "Saddam's loyalists thwart polygraph tests." Exerpt: Quote: Captured Saddam Hussein loyalists in Iraq are proving adept at beating lie-detector tests, frustrating attempts to find banned weapons and to learn what happened to Navy Capt. Michael Scott Speicher. U.S. officials and military officers say trained interrogators in Baghdad have caught Iraqi Ba'ath Party loyalists lying while hooked up to the machine, which showed they were not being deceptive. Officials attribute the lying to many factors. They say it may have become part of the culture of Saddam's regime to lie routinely. In other cases, the Iraqi intelligence service and Special Security Organization trained operators how to "beat" the machine. And there is the issue that polygraphs, which measure changes in heartbeat, respiration and perspiration, are simply not accurate.

	George W. Maschke I am generally available in the chat room from 3 AM to 3 PM Eastern time. Tel/SMS: 1-202-810-2105 (Please use Signal Private Messenger or WhatsApp to text or call.) E-mail/iMessage/FaceTime: antipolygraph.org@protonmail.com Wire: @ap_org Threema: A4PYDD5S Personal Statement: "Too Hot of a Potato"
	WWW Twitter YouTube IP Logged

orolan Especially Senior User Offline Posts: 363 Joined: Dec 25^th, 2002	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #1 - Jul 21^st, 2003 at 3:21pm	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	George, Gotta love that last sentence

	"Most of the things worth doing in the world had been declared impossible before they were done." &&U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis D. Brandeis
	WWW IP Logged

Anonymous Guest	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #2 - Jul 21^st, 2003 at 4:12pm	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	And here we have, courtesy of the U.S. Government, one more massive screw-up in the war on terrorism. We find ourselves fighting a 21st century war with third world technology and an experimental paradign/game plan with zero validity. Although people everywhere are now questioning whether Saddam's henchmen could have beat us (even had any to speak of) with WMDS, presumably nobody should be surprised about his beating us through polygraph exams...


	IP Logged

orolan Especially Senior User Offline Posts: 363 Joined: Dec 25^th, 2002	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #3 - Jul 21^st, 2003 at 4:33pm	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	They just have the wrong people over there doing the polygraphs. Perhaps the polygraphers frequenting this board, with their inate ability to sniff out CM's and their 82-100% rate of confessions should volunteer their services

	"Most of the things worth doing in the world had been declared impossible before they were done." &&U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis D. Brandeis
	WWW IP Logged

Saidme Especially Senior User Offline Posts: 311 Joined: Jun 11^th, 2003	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #4 - Jul 21^st, 2003 at 5:19pm	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	G-Man The article states: "U.S. officials and military officers say trained interrogators in Baghdad have caught Iraqi Ba'ath Party loyalists lying while hooked up to the machine, which showed they were not being deceptive." Sounds like a post-test interrogation to me. But I guess you wouldn't know much about that except what you've read in books. Orolan I can't believe it's as low as 82%. Gotta be in the 90's.


	IP Logged

orolan Especially Senior User Offline Posts: 363 Joined: Dec 25^th, 2002	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #5 - Jul 21^st, 2003 at 7:17pm	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	Saidme, I think it was Public Servant who threw out the 9 confessions out of 11 DI's, thus the 82%. Not as good as your 100%, but maybe he hasn't been doing it as long

	"Most of the things worth doing in the world had been declared impossible before they were done." &&U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis D. Brandeis
	WWW IP Logged

Saidme Especially Senior User Offline Posts: 311 Joined: Jun 11^th, 2003	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #6 - Jul 21^st, 2003 at 7:27pm	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	Not 100% but certainly up there.


	IP Logged

Human Subject Senior User Offline Posts: 73 Joined: May 31^st, 2003	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #7 - Jul 21^st, 2003 at 11:41pm	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	Saidme, why do you attribute the interrogators' success at discovering lies to the polygraph? I see nothing in the story to suggest they wouldn't have discovered the subjects' lies even if they weren't hooked up to polygraphs. There are plenty of other ways to discover deception, like comparing statements to the known facts, or comparing statements made by multiple subjects. The bottom line is the machines showed no deception even when the interrogators knew they were being deceived. Notice also that no mention is made of the interrogators detecting the use of countermeasures. They merely speculate that this is one possible explanation for the results. There's really nothing to this story that lends much support to our reliance on polygraphy.


	IP Logged

Human Subject Senior User Offline Posts: 73 Joined: May 31^st, 2003	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #8 - Jul 21^st, 2003 at 11:53pm	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	Here's an example from the full article. Quote: In one incident, an Iraqi involved in a weapons program was shown two pictures. In one, officials cut his image out of a photo of workers at a weapons factory. He agreed that the cut-out image was of him. They then showed him the full photo, with his image restored. This time, he denied that he was in the photo. The polygraph did not catch him in this blatant lie. Wonder what old Doc Marston would have to say about this? And we rely on this technology as a method of screening applicants to sensitive government and law enforcement posts? Nice. So these positions are now populated by applicants who were lucky, lack a conscience, are effective practitioners of countermeasures, or some combination thereof.


	IP Logged

Saidme Especially Senior User Offline Posts: 311 Joined: Jun 11^th, 2003	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #9 - Jul 22^nd, 2003 at 12:25am	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	HS Without an intimate knowledge of the interrogation you or I can't know exactly what took place. We can speculate (SWAG) all we want (which happens regularly here). In order to make an informed decision I think we would had to have been there. Wouldn't you agree?


	IP Logged

George W. Maschke Global Moderator Offline Make-believe science yields make-believe security. Posts: 6211 Joined: Sep 29^th, 2000	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #10 - Jul 22^nd, 2003 at 9:49am	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	I think it is clear from Rowan Scarborough's article that he has a high level Pentagon source who is telling him that the polygraph isn't working.

	George W. Maschke I am generally available in the chat room from 3 AM to 3 PM Eastern time. Tel/SMS: 1-202-810-2105 (Please use Signal Private Messenger or WhatsApp to text or call.) E-mail/iMessage/FaceTime: antipolygraph.org@protonmail.com Wire: @ap_org Threema: A4PYDD5S Personal Statement: "Too Hot of a Potato"
	WWW Twitter YouTube IP Logged

suethem Very Senior User Offline Posts: 196 Joined: Apr 29^th, 2003	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #11 - Jul 23^rd, 2003 at 11:41pm	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	I guess countermeasues do exist! It seems like they work too! Surely these polygraphers were amoung the best- Hmmm!


	IP Logged

Batman Very Senior User Offline Posts: 115 Joined: Jan 12^th, 2003	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #12 - Jul 23^rd, 2003 at 11:59pm	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	When you're polygraphing the biggest ASSHOLES in the world, you have to believe that their CM's will work. A really high level source in the Pentagon? Well let's see, maybe a Major or Lt Col, or an assistant to the assistants assistant to the Deputy Under Secretary for bullshit. Come on George, this is the media we're talking about here. They have even less credibility than polygraph examiners. BATMAN


	IP Logged

suethem Very Senior User Offline Posts: 196 Joined: Apr 29^th, 2003	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #13 - Jul 24^th, 2003 at 12:11am	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	Batman, Your statement just confirms that the techniques (CM's) work. If they work for terrorists, they work for regular citizens. I assume that they guys will be investigated thoroughly even though they have passed. I doubt there is anyone dumb enough in the Gov to stand by the polygraphers findings- although you never know...


	IP Logged

Saidme Especially Senior User Offline Posts: 311 Joined: Jun 11^th, 2003	Re: Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests Reply #14 - Jul 24^th, 2003 at 4:27am	Mark & Quote Quote Print Post
	What the hell is a regular citizen? I'm stymied! ???


	IP Logged

Pages: 1

Add Poll

Send Topic

‹ Previous Topic | Next Topic ›

Saddam's Loyalists Thwart Polygraph Tests

Name:
E-mail:
Your Verification Code is:	Please type the characters that appear in the image. The characters must be typed in the same order, and they are case-sensitive.
Verification Code:
Preview

Message Icon:

Subject:

Message:
You can resize the textbox by dragging the right or bottom border.

Max 200000 characters. Remaining characters:

Text size: pt

More Smilies

View All Smilies

Collapse/Expand additional features

Attachments More Attachments

Allowed file types: txt doc docx ics psd pdf bmp jpe jpg jpeg gif png swf zip rar tar gz 7z odt ods mp3 mp4 wav avi mov 3gp html maff pgp gpg
Maximum Attachment size: 500000 KB

Attachment 1:

Attachment 2:

Attachment 3:

Attachment 4:

Attachment 5:

Attachment 6:

Attachment 7:

Attachment 8:

Attachment 9:

Attachment 10:

Disable UBBC and Smilies:

Check this if you wish to disable parsing of ubbc tags and smilies.

Return To:

Select where you would like to return to after posting.